Sign the letter


A Call from the University of Toronto to President Melanie Woodin and Provost Trevor Young: Accept the Report on Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian Discrimination (MAP DWG)

November 20, 2026

Dear President Woodin and Provost Young,

We, the undersigned faculty, librarians, staff, students, instructors, fellows, research associates, unions, organizations, and alumni of the University of Toronto, urge you to reverse course and accept Over-Policed, Under-Protected, the final report of the Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian Discrimination Working Group (MAP DWG), and its 57 recommendations. We regard your public claim that you do not reject the report, but rather ‘do not accept the report as written,’ as a distinction without a difference.

This rejection sends a message of disregard to a large segment of our University community. It communicates that the University Administration does not trust Muslims, Arabs, and Palestinians to describe their own experience of discrimination, analyze its structural dimensions, and formulate constructive recommendations for change. This arrives after MAP DWG, at the request of the Administration, spent over two years gathering data and producing a report. The Administration’s acknowledgement that discrimination against these communities at the University is real does not mitigate its refusal to engage the report’s findings, analysis, and attention to the structural changes now required. Instead, this acknowledgement and rejection together convey that the Administration believes it has nothing to learn from Muslims, Arabs, and Palestinians about the definition of discrimination, whether it exists, and how to address it. The Administration’s posture of disdain and condescension reinforces the very patterns of racism, discrimination, and exclusion that participants in the MAP DWG process collected, documented, and shared.

The review process and rejection itself was MAP discrimination in practice. One of the central concerns the report identifies, by way of intimate and personal accounts of those who have experienced discrimination at the University, are the ways in which institutional practices are deployed in discriminatory ways. For five months, university staffers appointed by you and your senior administrative colleagues worked closely with the report’s authors to conduct a line-by-line review and edit of the initial draft of the report. The MAP DWG worked in good faith with your office to respond to queries and concerns, and produce an effective and acceptable report that accurately represented the experiences of MAP communities. After these efforts, with no further consultation and just 48 hours before the report’s release, the Administration notified the Working Group that it would reject the entire report and all recommendations. No prior report on discrimination by an equity-seeking group has been subjected to a months’ long scrutiny prior to release, and none has been rejected. The conduct of the Administration exhibits the lack of equal concern and respect for Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian members of the University community.

The corrective steps proposed by the Administration neither acknowledge nor address the scale and scope of the problems documented. The MAP DWG had a clear mandate: to examine anti-Muslim, anti-Arab, and anti-Palestinian discrimination at the University of Toronto and make recommendations to address this discrimination. The Working Group fulfilled their mandate. Its findings, carefully laid out in the 177-page report, emerged from an extensive institutional process involving 85 consultations across all three campuses, 525 survey responses, written submissions, and a review of university policies and practices. The report documents pervasive stereotypes, unequal scrutiny, discipline and repression of scholarship and advocacy on Palestine, inconsistent policy enforcement, inadequate protections against harassment and doxxing, and widespread distrust of complaint mechanisms. The report should be assessed against that mandate and the context in which this discrimination is experienced. The report’s findings point to systemic institutional problems that cannot be addressed through existing procedures alone, as members of the MAP DWG have publicly stated.

The Administration has cast doubt on confidential accounts of discrimination as ‘incomplete.’ The Working Group had neither the mandate nor capacity to conduct individual investigations. Its Terms of Reference meant that the Working Group could not require university administrators to meet with them, and several who were invited refused. The Administration did not challenge the personal accounts provided in prior reports of discrimination by other equity-seeking groups. The Administration should explain why it considers it necessary or appropriate to discredit Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian accounts of their experience.

The Administration’s suggestion that the MAP DWG report departs from previous equity reviews is an insufficient basis for rejecting it. Equity reviews cannot be assessed through a uniform framework that disregards distinct histories, local and global contexts, and the specific forms of racism and discrimination experienced by different communities. Each review must be evaluated in relation to its mandate and the harms it was established to examine. Each report is different from every other report, and these differences do not, by themselves, discredit their methods or findings. The Administration did not prescribe a template for the report and thus cannot treat departures from other reports as a basis for its rejection.

The University’s global outlook, partnerships, student community, research, and teaching all recognize that events beyond Canada’s borders matter. The global context is also vital to understanding how members of the University community experience racism and discrimination. This makes the University's objection to the report because of its "lengthy commentary on events abroad" unfathomable. It would have been irresponsible and unrigorous to exclude that context. The Administration has not explained why that context is irrelevant here. That response dismisses the testimony, analysis, and proposed remedies of the people the inquiry was meant to hear.

The report’s recommendations are concerned with protecting academic freedom, ensuring procedural fairness, and addressing discriminatory practices. These are obligations arising from the University’s own policies and Statement of Institutional Purpose. ‘Institutional restraint’ does not explain why the Administration cannot act on documented discrimination, harassment, reprisals, and unequal treatment. Nor do the proposed measures concerning prayer spaces, educational resources, and training answer the report’s findings about campus safety, policy enforcement, academic freedom, and institutional accountability.

The possible discomfort of some readers of the report does not invalidate the report’s conclusions or recommendations. The Administration undermines and dismisses the many people who shared their experiences by asserting that some Jewish and Israeli colleagues might be offended or upset by the report. The Administration should identify the specific language at issue and explain how that concern justifies rejecting the report and all its recommendations. Presumably, some readers of the reports on anti-Indigenous racism, anti-Black racism, anti-Asian racism, and/or antisemitism were also offended or upset. Prioritising the potential discomfort of some report readers takes the focus off Muslims, Arabs, and Palestinians as people who experience discrimination, and recasts them as perpetrators of offence to others whose discomfort matters more. This is further evidence of MAP discrimination at the University.

This is a matter of urgency. The report’s findings indicate that existing institutional practices are leaving Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian communities to face severe and ongoing discrimination. The Administration’s refusal to accept the report or any of its recommendations only validates the perception of disregard and distrust that the report documents. The University must show, through a substantive response and a clear implementation process, that these experiences and findings will be treated with seriousness and accountability. The non-endorsement disclaimer placed on every page of the published report undermines the legitimacy of a report commissioned by the University Administration, and the integrity of the University.

We therefore call on the University Administration to:
1. Accept the report, as it has done with each of the previous institutional equity Task Force reports.
2. Remove the shameful non-endorsement disclaimer from the published report.
3. Explain where and why it disagrees with specific text, findings, or analysis contained in the report.
4. Provide specific explanations for the rejection of each recommendation.
5. Submit the Administration’s explanatory response to a formal University governance and oversight process to ensure transparent scrutiny and institutional accountability.

We urge the University Administration to reverse its decision and accept the report in an effort to demonstrate that the concerns of Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian members of the University community will be treated with the dignity and institutional responsibility they deserve.

Signed by:

Your data will be processed according to the following privacy statement: PURPOSE: Pressure the university to accept the MAPDWG report and its recommendations. LEGITIMACY: By consent. You may withdraw your consent at any time. DATA CONTROLLER: Friends of MAPDWG.

Math captcha

4 + 9 =

Made with LiberaForms at my.liberaforms.org